I have no time for people who wrist off about how a movie isn't like a book. No shit, Sherlocks, movies aren't like books. Especially books like LOTR. I remember trying to read it when I was 12. I got through the first book and couldn't face the rest. Yawnalicious.
The movie, though
The locations are awesome. Maybe in our Feb-Mar trip to New Zealand we'll make a pilgrimage to some of the locations where they filmed. The kayaking on the river looked particularly dreamy. Of course, they somehow managed to find the 3 days a year when it doesn't rain, and I doubt we'll have that luck!
Next to see: Harry Potter.
--Nat
Not exactly the LAST person. (Score:1)
I can't stand theaters packed to the gills, I usually wait for movies to hit DVD before I see them. Cuts down on the rage.
Despite that, I did see Harry. It was, umm, beautifully filmed, cast and acted, and left me feeling flat. It's proof that the movie can't be like the book.
The best part of the movie is that I have visuals to go with my reading of the fifth book when it comes out this spring. Alan Rickman IS Snape.
Re:Not exactly the LAST person. (Score:1)
[ Although I'll probably wait for all the movies to finish before buying the DVDs, and get them in a set. ]
As to not films not being like the books, yes
Re:Not exactly the LAST person. (Score:2)
I saw LOTR opening week, and the theater was jammed, but when we saw Harry Potter after it had been out about two weeks, the theater was about half empty. Next weekend should be a good time to see it; DVDs and home theater systems won't do either of these movies any justice.
Re:Not exactly the LAST person. (Score:1)
LOTR (Score:1)
I saw the trailer today. It looks awesome.
Re:LOTR (Score:2)
Don't visit the movie mistakes site I URLed if you'd rather just sit back and enjoy the movie. But if you like easter eggs and don't mind occasionally going "oh cool, they were right, you can see his fake foot!" instead of whatever the directo
Saw it again (Score:1)
I spent an hour or so last night with my wife Chris discussing the changes between the book and the movie - they all seem to be well chosen to make the story fit the medium. The book has a lot of introspective thoughts from many of the characters; that gets old very fast if translated literally to the movie. So, for example, in the movie Frodo meets with Aragorn as he's leaving the company so that their con