What a mess. It almost sounds like those people who attacked "The Passion of the Christ" as anti-semitic, even though they hadn't seen it and it hadn't been released yet (I've not seen it, so I can't comment).
Hopefully, this will fall under the "no press is bad press" category.
Funny, I was going to make the same comparison. The fact that so many of the people were acting as though they had bought the book and felt gypped, when the book hasn't even left the warehouses, was a real tip-off.
As it is, I'm more likely to buy the book, now. Even if only out of spite:-). gnat has made another indirect sale...
Some of the criticism is valid. And, it has always been a double-edged sword of how do you trust someone who routinely violates trust. Every/. kiddie is going to be slapping his dick around on this one....brace yourselves.
Yeah....the people I know don't think much of him either. Even the 2600 crowd aren't all that keen on him as I remember. Most people in this business can be real assholes:) It's worse than Hollywood.
We'll see. I'll probably pick this book up, like I pick up every other security book, but it looks like it will suffer from the same flaw too many other security books suffer from. Too much high level wanking, and not enough hacking. I'm open to being pleasantly surprised though.
While to someone it may be kewl to read a book written by someone poking in from the outside, that is at worst pretty one-sided, and I think tells you little of what to do to harden your security. While it's often parroted that to catch a criminal you have to think like one to really get a balanced view you would need to have both sides covered. Those outside do what they do out of maliciouness/greed/boredom/intellectual challenge/fame in their own circles/financial gain, but those inside do have equally
Thanks, already sent you a reply.
I'd really like to see a good reverse engineering book with more of a pragmatic bent. If
someone from LSD, teso, or ADM could be convinced to write it with real examples for a technical audience it would be killer.
A good pragmatic book on code auditing would be nice as well. Something with plenty of real examples ideally written by someone who has published plenty of exploits (openbsd team would be nice, but unlikely).
Other than that, someone should talk to shok at w
Nobody here but us terrorists ... uh ... chickens (Score:2)
What a mess. It almost sounds like those people who attacked "The Passion of the Christ" as anti-semitic, even though they hadn't seen it and it hadn't been released yet (I've not seen it, so I can't comment).
Hopefully, this will fall under the "no press is bad press" category.
Re:Nobody here but us terrorists ... uh ... chicke (Score:1)
--rjray
Re:Nobody here but us terrorists ... uh ... chicke (Score:2)
Well, I'll certainly pick it up now that I know about it. Woo Hoo! gnat's made two whole sales! They're going to make him a marketing exec now :)
Re:Nobody here but us terrorists ... uh ... chicke (Score:2)
--Nat
Recent book (Score:2)
well.... (Score:2)
Re:well.... (Score:1)
Re:well.... (Score:2)
Re:well.... (Score:2)
--Nat
Re:well.... (Score:1)
Re:well.... (Score:2)
So what security books would people want to see?
--Nat
Re:well.... (Score:1)
I speak for a thousand silent brethren when I say High Volume Website Security Hacks! (I don't personally care, though.)
Re:well.... (Score:2)
Re:well.... (Score:1)