Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments
NOTE: use Perl; is on undef hiatus. You can read content, but you can't post it. More info will be forthcoming forthcomingly.

All the Perl that's Practical to Extract and Report

use Perl Log In

Log In

[ Create a new account ]

ajt (2546)

ajt
  (email not shown publicly)
http://www.iredale.net/

UK based. Perl, XML/HTTP, SAP, Debian hacker.

  • CPAN: ATRICKETT [cpan.org]
  • PerlMonks: ajt [perlmonks.org]
  • Local LUG: AdamTrickett [lug.org.uk]
  • Debian Administration: ajt [debian-adm...ration.org]
  • LinkedIn: drajt [linkedin.com]

Journal of ajt (2546)

Friday September 03, 2004
10:52 AM

Too Much Freedom

[ #20714 ]

RANDOM RANT

While on holiday I spoke at length with by brother-in-law. He has a semi-technical background, is deeply mis-trustful of Microsoft and is retired so he has time to kill. He should be a good candidate for Free and Open Software, if he can't be converted to some free things, then it's going to be hard to convert an awful lot of anyone else.

He started by reading some PC Magazines, and then he tried some Linux magazines (UK and French publications). He didn't joing his local LUG, which I think was a mistake. Based on the magazines and shop recommendations alone he picked SUSE Pro 8.x, and installed it.

His experiences of this exercise are as follows:

  • He HATES choosing things. Even within just one distro, he had too many choices. There is good evidence that too much choice is annoying and people don't like it, and I can understand that choices without knowleded is even more annoying and utterly pointless.
  • He tried to use Linux like Windows - mostly he expected the GUI to behave the same, this caused no end of problems as he found Linux didn't do what he expected.
  • He couldn't find or understand what he could find in the way of documentation.
  • Where is the shareware software? A lot of Windows users are use to small Windows shareware and freeware packages. Though they are easily subsituted with often superior open source packages, possibly even on the install disk, they are not mentioned, and he assumed they don't exist.
  • He is still using Windows 2000 as his main OS

Personally I think his first mistake was not finding someone local to help. He lives in Paris, and I think there are a few Linux/BSD types over there who could have helped, and know enough English to converse with him.

While a boxed distro may be a good idea, I think he picked the wrong one, something with less choice would have suited him a lot better. While unifying KDE and GNOME isn't going to happen in a rush - if at all, that kind of difference is very confusing to new users if not carefully explained...

I think the biggest thing that is required is a significant overhaul in documentation. This has touched a raw nerve both here and on Perlmonks, but a lot of documentation does assume you know what you are doing, and isn't suitable for new users. An obvious problem is that serious users of something, for example Perl, can't always see what a new users finds hard or needs explaining, and new users know what is hard, but don't know the answers.

I'm not saying that Windows is easier than Linux, rather that it has successfully maintained the myth that is easy, by trading lots of things like security and stability off against "apparent ease of use".

As a contrast, a colleage at work tried Knoppix, with some help from me, had no problems and has found that Google knows all. His wife used it, without even realising that it wasn't Windows XP...

The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
 Full
 Abbreviated
 Hidden
More | Login | Reply
Loading... please wait.
  • Freedom of choice is what you got. Freedom from choice is what you want.
    Emphasis added.
    --

    ------------------------------
    You are what you think.