So I'm trying to get my foot in the door of the Germanic languages by learning Yiddish -- learning to read it at least. Since almost everything written in Yiddish is written not in Latin script, but in Hebrew script, this mean I have to learn the Hebrew alphabet. It's absolutely maddening -- the letters simply look too much alike, even worse than Burmese. As much as I look at the alphabet charts and lists of common words, it all just looks like long rows of ]|]N"]'|]']N to me. "Hm, and which of the seven letters that looks like ] is that supposed to be?"
And the great thing about Hebrew is ... (Score:2)
... that to a non-speaker it looks valid upside-down, too! In fact, it looks better, because the horizontal lines at the top of each character look like a baseline.
I used Menahem Mansoor's Biblical Hebrew Step by Step, which had extensive exercises in the first lesson to help you learn to distinguish similar characters. Nearly every letter was paired with nearly every other letter, it seemed.
It's not too bad, once you get the hang of it, though. I'm completely out of practice but can still distinguis
J. David works really hard, has a passion for writing good software, and knows many of the world's best Perl programmers
Three cheers for scripts! (Score:1)
I can imagine that non-speakers (or more to the point, illiterates) of quite a few scripts could have trouble knowing the correct orientatio
Learn Hebrew First (Score:2)
Any good introductory text will have a few chapters on learning the alphabet. It's actually reasonably simple to learn the Hebrew alphabet, because it's all phonetic. There are only a few exceptions to the pronunciation in [Sephardic] Hebrew. Also, spelling is very regular and almost algebraic enough to be mechanical in some cases, without losing a sense of poetry. Modern Hebrew
Re:Learn Hebrew First (Score:2)
But learning Hebrew in order to learn Yiddish sounds really the long way around. I mean, Yiddish borrows a lot of nouns from Hebrew, but I don't see how one would have to know all the scary details of the Hebrew's morphology and syntax, to say nothing of its kooky vowel-marking system.
Re:Learn Hebrew First (Score:2)
I believe that Yiddish does use Hebrew vowels. It also adds some vowels of its own I think (using Hebrew consonants to mimic the Germanic spelling or something).
The usage of vowels is so regular in Hebrew that it's possible to ignore (once you know what vowels are typically used where), and the redundancy tends not to be necessary once you've got a firm
Re:Learn Hebrew First (Score:2)
Not [salon.com] really. [yivoinstitute.org]
In fact, the only vowel pointing in the system is the squiggle under the alef to distinguish it from a silent (word-initial) alef. YIVO says to use one squiggle to show it's an /o/ and another to show it's a /a/, but apparently some people [amazon.com] don't distinguish those vowels at all. (Incidentally, merging those two vowels is actually relatively common in Germanic languages, I think.)
Re:Learn Hebrew First (Score:2)
Distinguishing characteristics (Score:1)
The big problem, especially when dealing with printed text, is knowing which bits of a letter are the important ones that distinguish it from other letters, and that doesn't seem to be covered well often enough. I can imagine someone trying to write a T by painstakingly copying the printed T, complete with