Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments
NOTE: use Perl; is on undef hiatus. You can read content, but you can't post it. More info will be forthcoming forthcomingly.

All the Perl that's Practical to Extract and Report

use Perl Log In

Log In

[ Create a new account ]

Purdy (2383)

Purdy
  jasonNO@SPAMpurdy.info
http://purdy.info/
AOL IM: EmeraldWarp (Add Buddy, Send Message)
Yahoo! ID: jpurdy2 (Add User, Send Message)

Bleh - not feeling creative right now. You can check me out on PerlMonks [perlmonks.org].

Journal of Purdy (2383)

Wednesday December 08, 2004
04:52 PM

Busy busy...

[ #22217 ]

I think I'm getting the hang of this CPAN thing! Unfortunately, Mark Stosberg threw me a curve by introducing me to Module::Build, so now I'm wondering what's the best way to build CPAN modules ... the Makefile.PL way or the Build.PL way? Guess I need to buy Writing Perl Modules for CPAN.

Anyway, I have released two new-from-scratch modules:

I'm also starting to prepare for my trip. I hope I can find my power adapter. I'm not sure what to pack for the weather (besides rain ;)) - my expat friend says now's an arctic time, but weather.com says it'll be around 50. Must be that global warming... ;)

Peace,

Jason

The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
 Full
 Abbreviated
 Hidden
More | Login | Reply
Loading... please wait.
  • so now I'm wondering what's the best way to build CPAN modules ... the Makefile.PL way or the Build.PL way? Guess I need to buy Writing Perl Modules for CPAN.

    I don't think that Module::Build existed when that book was written. I'm always slightly annoyed when I run a Build.PL script that wasn't written with create_makefile_pl => traditional. If EU::MM is already installed and works, why should I have to go and install another module in order to build this one?

    That said I suppose if M::B become

  • I like Ken Williams' work a lot, but Module::Build is not shipped with Perl. Don't use Module::Build unless you have a problem that it solves better than MakeMaker. That would be something like interactive questions for the user.

    Alternatively, support both equally well by using the "traditional" option for creating a Makefile.PL from Module::Build. Otherwise I would have to install Module::Build on every machine where I want to put your module, for no good reason.

    • I too really like Module::Build and use it exclusively when developing internal projects. However, I think that wisdom of the previous two posters prevails until such time as M::B is shipping with a mainstream version of Perl.

      Because I haven't released many modules to CPAN, I didn't even realize M::B could generate a traditional Makefile.PL. Indeed the create_makefile_pl parameter to new() in conjunction with Module::Build::Compat should generate the file as Perrin describes. Cool!

      • Doh, I also meant to mention ExtUtils::ModuleMaker [cpan.org] which I use for creating my base packages. It can generate EU::MM, M::B, or M::B with a proxy Makefile.PL packages. The latter option isn't much help to you since it would still require M::B to be installed on the target system (it's like the 'small' style of create_makefile_pl).

  • If you're releasing stuff to CPAN you should take a look at Module::Release, and the associated release(1) command, which makes the process much easier.

    And if you do use Module::Release with either Subversion or Module::Build then you should probably look at Module::Release::Extras too...

    N

    • I found Module::Release::Extras on the CPAN but not Module::Release. Can you give a link?

      • Er, that's odd. It certainly used to be on CPAN. Last I knew, brian d foy was planning a new release -- you can see this from the horses mouth [perl.org].

        There's "release" on CPAN, listed under brian's software list, but that looks like it's a very old version (from before release(1) was split out in to Module::Release). I wonder if brian's uploaded an old version by mistake at some point.

      • There is apparently bad reindexing bummers running around. Apparenlty I have the latest release, but I'm no longer the registered owner since brian came back.

        Please ping brian directly and ask him to upload a new one, if only to get the version bumped, and then I'll delete all my versions.

        --

        --
        xoa