Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments
NOTE: use Perl; is on undef hiatus. You can read content, but you can't post it. More info will be forthcoming forthcomingly.

All the Perl that's Practical to Extract and Report

use Perl Log In

Log In

[ Create a new account ]

Kelli (7455)

Kelli
  (email not shown publicly)

Journal of Kelli (7455)

Wednesday February 21, 2007
11:56 AM

Why is it so hard to submit a bug?

[ #32463 ]

Bug tracking sites that don't do a good job at letting people submit problems don't make sense to me.

Case in point, my experience this morning:

Logging into my favorite messaging client, I found a bug. It was a pretty obscure bug at that.

Knowing that developers like to know of bugs, even when they're small and obscure, I go to the appropriate website and look for the bug system. There was no link clearly marked as "Submit your bug here!", which is fine. I find the appropriate page through the "Support" link.

I tried to search for the problem first, didn't find it in their bug system or in the wiki. It is a pretty obscure thing, so I wasn't really surprised.

When I tried to submit a bug, first I had to create an account. Why oh why do I have to create an account seperately? (Aside: Tabbed browsing is really the only way to go. I don't want to imagine going through this with one browser window.) Then when I tried to create an account, the bug software borked. No "Account Created" confirmation, just Python tracescript.

So I submitted a bug to the bug creator software people, like the page told me to. Luckily, their site let me submit a bug without an account. About 2 hours later, I get a response saying "Sorry, you should report this incident to the administrators of [site I tried to create account on]. This may be a local configuration issue. If not, they'll have the possibility to create a ticket on [bug software site]." I give them credit for the prompt response.

I'd love to submit a bug report to them, but I've already established that I can't create a account to submit a bug! Why couldn't they just forward it to the right system? The site I wanted to submit a bug to was a client and/or user of the bug software. You'd think that they would have the built-in ability reassign the bug to any of their client software systems. Maybe this is too much to ask, but at this point, I'm pretty frustrated.

Bug reporting shouldn't be so intimidating, so confusing, or so difficult.

A more ideal experience would include:

1. When you attempt to submit a bug, it should intelligently search the archives for potential matches, and let you see them. There shouldn't be a seperate step to manually search the bug archives. Integrated bug history and wiki search. Brilliant!
2. A number of fields don't make sense or aren't clear to the casual user. These should be optional and identified as such. Priority? Assigned to? Severity? Give those a default as "Don't know". You may want to take the "Assigned to" field out of the submission process, depending.
3. Post bug submit, if your email address doesn't have an account, offer to create one. Otherwise, let the bug go through as "anonymous", w/ or w/o the email address. Or if you'd rather (to prevent spamming of the bug tracking system), require the person to finish creating an account before the bug is officially submitted. Streamline account creation.

I'll have to take some time this afternoon and figure out who to send appropriate emails to for the now 2 bugs I have encountered. It's now past the point where it's too much trouble to even bother, but I'm going to be stubborn about this.

Note: This was written more as a rant and not as a full-featured "this is what's wrong with bug tracking systems today" commentary.

The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
 Full
 Abbreviated
 Hidden
More | Login | Reply
Loading... please wait.
  • Why oh why do I have to create an account seperately?

    Spam.

  • I’ve already established that I can’t create a account to submit a bug! Why couldn’t they just forward it to the right system?

    What makes you think the bug tracker creators have better ways to contact a bug tracker user project than you?

    You’d think that they would have the built-in ability reassign the bug to any of their client software systems. Maybe this is too much to ask, but at this point, I’m pretty frustrated.

    Yes, that is definitely too much to ask.

    Right there

    • That's quite a story - and I believe that it's real. I've dealt with similar people in the past.

      The bug passing between bug systems is really a pipe dream. Realistically, I realize it's not feasible in most cases. But wouldn't it be nice if you could say "not my bug - it belongs to this other module or program" and then the bug listing magically appears in that other program's bug tracker?

      Too much opportunity for abuse, probably. But it would save me the trouble of reentering the same bug in another sys